Holidays '08 Compact Camera Group Test Group 1: Budget cameras (sub $150)

In the first of our five group tests of compact digital cameras, we're looking at what are best termed 'budget' models. We've not gone for the absolute cheapest of the cheap (you can, after all buy a digital camera/ webcam thingy for as little as $20) but have chosen entry-level models from the major manufacturers with a price bar of $150. Our selection was made based on a variety of criteria, including popularity (best-sellers), price/feature balance and worldwide availability. There are so many sub $150 cameras on the market that we could only ever get a snapshot (excuse the pun) of what's available.

The days when buying a budget camera meant going 'off brand' and settling for a plastic toy with a couple of megapixels and no screen are long gone. These days you can get an awful lot of camera for $100-150, and most of the models here aren't even at the bottom of their respective ranges. Resolutions range from 7-10 megapixels (though as you'll see later this has an almost directly inverse relationship with the image quality) and towards the higher end of our price bracket you can expect advanced features such as face detection, image stabilization and slightly more exotic zoom lenses to start appearing. A couple of the cameras on test here even offer full photographic control with manual and semi manual exposure modes, making them perfect for the budding photographer looking to learn a little bit more about advanced shooting techniques.

For the purpose of these group tests we've abandoned most of our studio based tests, partly because the small differences between the various models won't impact on the typical user, partly because otherwise it would be next holiday season before we finished them otherwise. Instead we've concentrated more on the real world use of the cameras and on how they compare when used as they're intended to be - for standard sized prints (6x4 or 5x7 inches) or viewing full screen. Our photographic tests include studio comparisons and real world shots in good light, at night and in a typical social situation using flash.

The test cameras

From a list of around 40 camera we finally narrowed our selection down to nine models ranging from around $90 to just under $150. The cameras range from the simplest plastic point and shoot to fully featured enthusiast models, with a selection of metal bodied 'style' cameras in the middle.

Canon Powershot A470
Canon Powershot A590 IS
Fujifilm FinePix Z20fd
Kodak Easyshare C1013
Nikon Coolpix L18
Olympus FE-360
Panasonic Lumix DMC-LZ8
Samsung L210
Sony Cybershot DSC-W120

Key Spec compared

As we've discovered over the years the bare specification of a camera tells us precious little about how good it is, but it does at least give us a starting point for our comparison. In this table by far the most important figures are the zoom range, screen resolution and presence of an optical image stabilization system. You can basically ignore the sensor pixel count as it makes virtually no difference to your pictures at this level.


Canon A470	• 1/2.5" CCD • 7.1 MP	100- 1600	38-132mm	-	• 2.5" • 115k	SDHC/ SD	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 20fps	$104
Canon A590 IS	• 1/2.5" CCD • 8.0 MP	80- 1600	35-140mm	• Lens	• 2.5" • 115k	SDHC/ SD	Auto, P, A, S, M + Senes	• 640x480 • 20fps	$130
Fujifilm Z20fd	• 1/2.3" CCD • 10.0 MP	64- 1600	35-105mm	-	• 2.5" • 150k	SDHC/ SD/xD	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 30fps • MPEG	$130
Kodak C1013	• 1/2.3" CCD • 10.3 MP	80- 1000	34-102mm	-	• 2.4" • 115k	SDHC/ SD	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 15fps	$130
Nikon L18	• 1/2.5" CCD • 8.0 MP	64- 1600	35-105mm	-	• 3.0" • 230k	SDHC/ SD	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 30fps	$112
Olympus FE-360	• 1/2.35" CCD • 8.0 MP	80- 1600	36-108mm	-	• 2.5" • 154k	xD	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 15fps	$114
Panasonic LZ8	• 1/2.5" CCD • 8.1 MP	100- 1600	32-160mm	• Lens	• 2.5" • 230k	SDHC/ SD	Auto, P, A, S, M + Senes	• 640x480 • 30fps	$120
Sony W120	• 1/2.5" CCD • 7.2 MP	100- 3200	32-128mm	• Lens	• 2.5" • 115k	Memory stick	Auto + Scenes	• 640x480 • 30fps • MPEG	$148
Samsung L210	• 1/2.33" CCD • 10.2 MP	80- 1600	37-111mm	• Yes	• 2.5" • 230k	SDHC/ SD	Auto + Scenes, M	• 800x592 • 20fps • MPEG	$135